I was recently asked the question regarding my thoughts on programme restrictions by section for activities in scouting.
So what do you think about programme restrictions by section? –
Should there be restrictions on activities for certain age groups e.g. Cubs can abseil, scouts can climb but indoor only and explorers can climb outdoors single pitch and network can do an outdoor multi-pitch. Or should it be up to the young person’s ability to tackle the challenge?
I would have to say I see no reason for programme restriction by section. I can see why people would ask for it, with more and more young people driving their leaders to provide the adventure in scouting there are beavers doing activities which previously were only started at maybe a scouting level. However, I wonder if this is a cop-out from leaders. Are leaders looking for restriction because the drive for adventure by young people is making them have to think a little more about their programme?
Take my climbing example, if the beavers have been climbing at the indoor climbing centre down the road and then the cubs do the same by the time the young person gets to scouts and the suggestion is let’s go climbing they are going to be keen and interest, however, you’re going to have to look at somewhere different to do it.
If you just take them up the climbing centre again then you will not engage them and they will very quickly lose interest. That said it is not that difficult to get them outdoors and on to real rock or get them starting to lead.
There will be some activities that have a natural selection take water activities like kayaking beavers are more than likely going to be just getting water confidence but even something small like a rotobat is going to be very difficult for a beaver to paddle, at cubs they will be able to start to paddle and understand about the boat ready for scouts and explorers to start tackling things like the BCU star system.
The Scout Association programme is based on progressive learning and in my opinion, you would want young people to start that progression as early as possible any programme restrictions would only act as a barrier to progression. As someone who has taught kayaking to scouts, believe me, the earlier they get in a boat and understand that it will rock and that if it goes over your buoyancy aid will pull you to the surface the better. Getting some experience of falling out of a boat etc makes life so much easier later on.
There is always a way to make a challenge or task harder you just need to sit down and think about it a little maybe communicate (now there is a novel concept) with those section above and below you so are aware of what experience a young person is likely to have and thus plan accordingly.
Take this for Pioneering – Pioneering Unleashed